Last reviewed: Next review due:
13 min readThe Defamation and Malicious Publication (Scotland) Act 2021
Scotland's defamation law is governed not by the Defamation Act 2013 — which applies to England, Wales, and Northern Ireland — but by the Defamation and Malicious Publication (Scotland) Act 2021, an Act of the Scottish Parliament. The 2021 Act broadly mirrors the 2013 Act but contains important differences:
- Serious harm threshold:a statement is not defamatory unless it has caused or is likely to cause serious harm to the claimant's reputation.
- Defences: truth, honest opinion, and publication on a matter of public interest are all available in broadly the same form as in English law.
- Malicious publication: Scotland retains a distinct cause of action for falsehoods that cause economic loss — broadly equivalent to the English tort of malicious falsehood — under a modernised statutory form.
- No direct single publication rule equivalent: journalists should take Scottish law advice on limitation where online publications targeting Scottish audiences are at issue.
Scottish contempt of court
The Contempt of Court Act 1981 applies across the UK, so the strict liability rule — which makes it an offence to publish material that creates a substantial risk of serious prejudice to active proceedings — operates in Scotland in the same way as in England. However, distinctive Scottish features include:
- The Lord Advocate(the Scottish Government's chief law officer) has historically led contempt prosecutions in Scotland.
- The High Court of Justiciary is the supreme criminal court in Scotland; there is no Crown Court equivalent.
- Scottish jury culture and judicial attitudes mean that Scottish courts have sometimes taken a stricter view of pre-trial publicity risk in solemn procedure cases.
Scottish privacy law
Scotland has no dedicated privacy statute. Scottish courts apply the Human Rights Act 1998 (Articles 8 and 10) alongside Scots private law of confidentiality. The doctrinal underpinning in Scotland is the common law of confidence rather than the English misuse of private information tort, but the practical outcome is broadly similar. UK GDPR applies uniformly across all four nations.
Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 (FOISA)
FOISA 2002 is a separate Act of the Scottish Parliament covering Scottish public authorities. It is enforced by the Scottish Information Commissioner (OSIC) — not the UK ICO. Scottish authorities subject to FOISA include:
- The Scottish Government and its agencies
- Scottish local councils
- Scottish NHS boards and health bodies
- Scottish universities and further education colleges
- Police Scotland and the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service
Appeals from OSIC decisions go to the Upper Tribunal for Scotland. Journalists targeting Scottish public bodies must use FOISA, not FOIA 2000, and must direct complaints to OSIC.
Environmental Information (Scotland) Regulations 2004
Scotland has its own parallel Environmental Information Regulations, separately enacted from the EIR 2004 which applies in England, Wales, and Northern Ireland. Both implement the same Aarhus Convention obligations and both are enforced by their respective information commissioners — OSIC in Scotland, the ICO elsewhere. The substantive rights and exemption structure are very similar, but Scottish journalists should use the Scottish Regulations when requesting environmental information from Scottish authorities.
Reporting restrictions in Scottish courts
Scottish criminal procedure operates on solemn (jury) and summary (sheriff or JP) procedure. Key reporting restriction points include:
- The Contempt of Court Act 1981 applies; active proceedings restrictions are the same in principle as in England.
- Children referred to a Children's Hearing under the Children's Hearings (Scotland) Act 2011 have statutory anonymity; reporting restrictions are strict.
- Lord Justice Clerk's Practice Directions govern procedural matters in the High Court of Justiciary.
- There is no Scottish equivalent of the English Magistrates' Court reporting restriction framework; sheriff summary procedure applies instead.
Fatal Accident Inquiries
In Scotland, sudden or unexplained deaths — and deaths in specified circumstances such as deaths in custody or at work — are investigated by a Fatal Accident Inquiry (FAI) rather than a coroner's inquest. FAIs are governed by the Fatal Accidents and Sudden Deaths etc. (Scotland) Act 2016 and are heard by a sheriff sitting without a jury.
- The sheriff issues a determination (not a verdict) setting out the established facts of the death, including time, place, and cause.
- The sheriff may make findings as to reasonable precautions that might have prevented the death and any defects in any system of work.
- An FAI cannot make findings as to fault, blame, or civil or criminal liability — a critical difference from the English jury inquest which can return a conclusion of unlawful killing.
Scotland vs England: four key differences
Defamation statute
Scotland: Defamation and Malicious Publication (Scotland) Act 2021
England & Wales: Defamation Act 2013
FOI body
Scotland: Scottish Information Commissioner (OSIC)
England & Wales: UK Information Commissioner's Office (ICO)
Death investigation
Scotland: Fatal Accident Inquiry (sheriff)
England & Wales: Coroner's inquest (coroner)
Supreme criminal court
Scotland: High Court of Justiciary
England & Wales: Crown Court / Court of Appeal (Criminal Division)
Primary sources
Frequently asked questions
Does the Defamation Act 2013 apply in Scotland?
No. The Defamation Act 2013 applies to England, Wales, and Northern Ireland only. Scotland's defamation law was reformed by the Defamation and Malicious Publication (Scotland) Act 2021, which is a separate Act of the Scottish Parliament. The 2021 Act closely follows the 2013 Act — it introduces a serious harm threshold, defences of truth, honest opinion, and publication on a matter of public interest — but it contains some distinct provisions, including separate treatment of malicious publication (a claim for economic loss caused by false statements of fact).
What is the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 and how does it differ from FOIA?
FOISA 2002 is the Scottish Parliament's equivalent of the Freedom of Information Act 2000. It applies to Scottish public authorities — the Scottish Government, local councils in Scotland, Scottish NHS bodies, Scottish universities, and others. It is enforced by the Scottish Information Commissioner (OSIC), not the UK Information Commissioner's Office. While the structure is broadly similar to FOIA, there are differences in exemptions, timescales, and review procedures. Scottish journalists making FOI requests to Scottish public authorities should use FOISA, not FOIA.
What are Fatal Accident Inquiries and how do they differ from inquests in England?
In Scotland, deaths that are sudden, unexplained, or occur in specified circumstances (such as deaths in custody or at work) are investigated by a Fatal Accident Inquiry (FAI), not a coroner's inquest. FAIs are heard by a sheriff, not a coroner. They are governed by the Fatal Accidents and Sudden Deaths etc. (Scotland) Act 2016. Instead of a conclusion (as in England's reformed coroner system), the sheriff issues a determination setting out the cause of death, and may make findings as to precautions that could have prevented the death. Crucially, an FAI cannot make findings as to fault or blame.
Does Scottish contempt law differ from English contempt law?
The Contempt of Court Act 1981 applies across the UK, so the strict liability rule and the active proceedings framework are the same in Scotland. However, Scottish practice around contempt has some distinctive features. The Lord Advocate has historically played a central role in contempt prosecutions. Scottish jury trial takes place only on solemn procedure before the High Court of Justiciary or the Sheriff Court — there is no separate Crown Court. Scottish judges have historically been regarded as applying a stricter approach to pre-trial publicity in jury cases.
How does Scottish privacy law operate without a distinct Privacy Act?
Like England and Wales, Scotland has no dedicated statutory privacy law. Scottish courts apply the law of confidentiality and the Human Rights Act 1998 (Articles 8 and 10) to balance privacy against freedom of expression. Scots private law of confidentiality has historically recognised the breach of confidence action. After the HRA 1998 came into force, Scottish courts, like English courts, developed the misuse of private information tort — though in Scotland the doctrinal underpinning remains the common law of confidence rather than a separate English-style tort. UK GDPR applies uniformly across Scotland, England, Wales, and Northern Ireland.